Prepared by Tony Beddow from contemporaneous notes on 10 March 2014
Chair’s opening remarks
1. The Chair referred to the suggested timing of items. The fixed ending time of 3pm was challenged. It was stated that this was fixed by the staff availability at Unite. The suggested timing was agreed.
A point of order was raised concerning the point at which the newly elected Chair would assume control of the meeting. Noted: the Constitution was silent on the matter and there were no Standing Orders. Noted: practice in the Labour party was for new officers to assume their position immediately after outgoing officers had reported. One member of Central Council opined that the practice of the SHA differed.
2. The order of items was discussed; noted – the election count was underway and the results would not be known for some time. Noted – the reports of officers undertaking the scrutiny of the election may need to move to the end of the agenda. It was moved and agreed that items 9 a-f would be taken after the report of the Governance group and items 9g- v.
3. The Chair asked if the meeting would accept the attendance of non members; it was moved and agreed that a co-opted member of Central Council (who was not an individual member) be allowed to stay; it was noted that that co-opted member would not be able to vote. That attendee left the meeting.
Agenda item 1 Apologies were noted
Agenda item 2 Minutes of the 2013 AGM were approved
Agenda item 3 There were no matters arising
Agenda items 4 Results of ballot. This could not be taken at the meeting as the count had not been completed by 3pm and the close of the meeting
Agenda item 5 New members of Central Council nominated by branches were noted, as was the possibility that these might change depending on the results of item 4
Agenda item 6 a) David Mattocks and Dr Tom Fitzgerald were re-elected as auditors
6 (b) Delegates to party conference was deferred to the CC
6 (c) Patrick French, Jos Bell, and Dr Shibley Rahman were nominated as delegates to the Socialist Societies; CC should also add others
Agenda item 7 (a) The Chair’s report was noted without debate
7 (b) The Directors report was noted without debate
7 (c) The membership report was received and questions raised on its clarity and accuracy. The report was not accepted.
7 (d) The report on On line presence was referred (without discussion) to Central Council; members had had difficulty accessing it via the web site
Agenda item 8 The Finance and Audit report was received. Queries were raised on:
i) The absence of any reference to liabilities for which financial provision should be made – notably a sum for redundancy payments.
ii) The absence of clarity about the provision of reserves
iii) An apparent contradiction between this report and that covered under item 7 (c) concerning membership data.
The auditors were not present to deal with the queries. The report was not accepted. It was noted that any membership discrepancies might affect the results of the ballot.
Agenda item 9 Report of the Governance group and proposed Constitutional amendments
The Report was introduced by the Chair, supported by each member of the Group, The purpose of each of the themes underpinning the proposed changes was explained. With that background item 9g-v was taken.
Item 9 g This change did not attain the necessary two third majority
Item 9 h This change was carried
Item 9i This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Item 9j This change was carried
Item 9 k This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Item 9l This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Item 9m This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Item 9n This change was carried
Item 9o This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Item 9p This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Item 9q This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Item 9r This change was carried
Item 9s This change did not attain the necessary two third majority
Item 9t This change did not attain the necessary two third majority
Item 9u This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Item 9v This change did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Items 9 a-f These did not attain the necessary two thirds majority
Agenda Item 10 Resolutions
Item 10 a Agreed: officers were to bring their proposals for managing complaints and grievances to Central Council for agreement.
10 b Agreed : The document Response to Labour’s Final Year Document would be referred to Central Council.
10 c Agreed: The proposal regarding the Communications Group would be referred to Central Council.
10 d The Resolution was amended to read “The AGM of the SHA reaffirms the SHA’s opposition to NHS privatisation and notes” etc. The motion was carried.
10 e The item was received after the deadline for business. It was not discussed, but referred to Central Council for consideration.
Agenda item 11
11 a This was briefly discussed and a view offered that affiliation to the NHS Alliance should cease. The meeting concluded with agreement that this item be discussed at Central Council.
The meeting concluded at 1500hrs, No further business was conducted. Items 11b,12, 13, 14 and 15 were not reached.